Why is My Pizza Dough Hard? Understanding the Causes and Solutions

Dear reader, if you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission to help support the blog - at no extra cost to you.
5/5 - (8 votes)

There’s nothing quite as disappointing as biting into a slice of pizza only to find that the dough is hard and tough to chew.

So, why is my pizza dough hard? It’s a frustrating question that many of us have asked ourselves at some point, especially if we’ve put time and effort into making our own pizza from scratch.

In this blog post, we’ll explore the reasons behind hard pizza dough and give you the tips and tricks you need to ensure that your pizza dough turns out perfectly every time.

From the importance of proper kneading to the role of temperature and humidity, we’ll cover everything you need to know about making soft and delicious pizza dough.

So, if you’re tired of tough and unappetizing pizza crusts, keep reading and discover the secrets to perfect pizza dough every time.

Why is My Pizza Dough Hard?

Kneading your pizza dough by hand can sometimes lead to a mistake caused by not being patient enough. The result is a tough and hard dough ball that’s difficult to handle, full of holes and cracks, and won’t stick together.

It is essential to carefully follow your recipe to get the right consistency.

Adding too much flour to your dough can cause it to be too dry, resulting in a rough texture and cracks. To address this issue, you can incorporate water gradually back into the dough.

Use a bowl and a teaspoon to add water a little bit at a time while continually kneading the dough until it reaches the desired consistency.

It’s vital to stick to your recipe. If it says 200 grams of flour, use exactly 200 grams – don’t add more.

Kneading on a floured surface may temporarily fix stickiness but can also disrupt the balance of your recipe.

It is better not to knead on a floured surface, and if your recipe suggests you do so, consider trying a different one.

Being patient is key. Proper kneading takes time, and your pizza dough will eventually reach the right consistency.

Fixing a hard dough should be considered as plan B since it’s time-consuming and can stress your dough. It’s always better to have a good dough in the first place to avoid additional work.

After properly kneading and shaping your dough, it should be smooth and soft, ready to proof, and become a delicious pizza.

Remember to keep practicing and experimenting with different recipes to discover the one that works best for you.

By patiently kneading and sticking to the correct measurements, you’ll be able to achieve the perfect pizza dough.

Related post:

How Long Can You Store Pizza Dough in the Refrigerator?

Is It Safe to Thaw Pizza Dough in the Microwave?

Does Pizza Dough Have Eggs? A Quick Guide to Egg-Free Pizza Dough

The Best Round Table Pizza Dough Recipe for Homemade Pizza

Rolling vs Stretching Pizza Dough: Which is Better?

Identifying the Problem

Kneading Process

One of the most common issues you might face when kneading dough by hand is becoming impatient. This can lead to a hard, difficult-to-handle dough ball that’s full of holes and cracks and doesn’t stick together.

It’s important to remember that following a recipe and maintaining a balance of ingredients is crucial to achieving a good dough consistency.

Dough Consistency

You might find that adding more flour, especially when kneading on a floured surface, can contribute to the hardness of the dough. This occurs because the extra flour disturbs the balance of your recipe, which can cause the dough to be too dry.

If your dough appears similar to this—with cracks all over and not sticking together—it’s time to fix it!

Try using a bowl and adding water little by little using a teaspoon. Slowly incorporate the water into the dough, continuing to add it in rounds until you’re satisfied with the result and the hardness is gone.

Sticking to the recipe’s specified amount of flour and avoiding additional adjustments is essential. Kneading on a floured surface can be a double-edged sword, fixing stickiness but ruining the overall consistency.

Remember, patience is key in kneading dough to achieve the right texture. Always consider the method of incorporating additional water as a plan B.

Adding too much water will stress the dough, but it shouldn’t affect the quality of your pizza in the end. However, achieving good dough on the first try is preferable.

After fixing the dough consistency, your dough should be smooth, soft, and ready to proof, eventually becoming a delicious pizza. Stay patient, follow the recipe, and avoid making adjustments for the best results.

Fixing the Dough

Using a Bowl and Teaspoon

When you notice that your dough is hard, dry, and difficult to handle, it’s important to fix it before it ruins your pizza. Grab a bowl and a teaspoon because you’re going to need them to slowly add water back into the dough.

Remember, this “fixing” process should always be considered as a plan B. Ideally, you’d want to get the dough right in the first place, following your recipe precisely without adding extra flour to balance stickiness.

Incorporating Water

Start by adding a small amount of water, just a little at a time, to the dough using a teaspoon. This process should be done in several rounds until you’re satisfied with the consistency of the dough and it’s no longer hard.

Be patient while incorporating the water, as this can take some time. Not rushing through this step is crucial, as you don’t want to stress your dough.

Once you’ve successfully incorporated the water, let the dough rest for about 10 minutes. After the resting period, gently reshape your dough ball. The final result should be smooth, soft, and ready to proof and turn into a delicious pizza.

Fixing the Dough

Important Takeaways

Stick to the Recipe

When you’re trying to knead a perfect dough, it’s essential that you stick to the recipe. If it says to use a specific amount of flour, for example, 200 grams, then make sure you only use that amount.

Adding more flour can lead to an imbalance in the recipe and result in a hard, unmanageable dough. So, always follow the recipe to get the best results.

Avoiding Floured Surface

While kneading your dough, you may be tempted to use a floured surface. However, this can also disrupt the balance of your recipe.

Instead of resorting to a floured surface, you should work on being patient during the kneading process. It might take some time, but eventually, your dough will become just right.

Remember—this should be considered a “Plan B,” as getting a good dough in the first place is preferable.

By sticking to the recipe and avoiding floured surfaces, you’ll be well on your way to creating a delicious dough for your pizza.

It’s important that you continue to knead the dough patiently and let it proof in order to achieve those satisfying, soft, and smooth results. Happy baking!

Final Results

Reshaping the Dough

After less than ten minutes, it’s time to gently reshape your dough ball. With patience and perseverance, you will eventually achieve a soft, smooth, and pliable dough that’s perfect for making pizza.

Ready for Proofing

Now that your dough has been properly reshaped, it’s ready to proof and transform into a delicious pizza.

Following the process outlined in the video, you should end up with a beautiful, nicely textured pizza that everyone will enjoy.

Remember to stick to your recipe and avoid adding excessive flour while kneading. With practice, you’ll find the perfect balance that results in fantastic pizza dough every time. Happy baking!

Final Results


If you find that your dough is hard, not sticking together, and full of cracks, it’s time to fix it.

To begin, use a bowl and a teaspoon to gradually incorporate small amounts of water into the dough. Be patient and continue adding water until the dough reaches a smoother texture.

Remember, this process should be considered a Plan B, as it’s better to have a good dough to start with to avoid stressing the dough.

Sticking to your recipe is crucial, as adding more flour than specified can throw off the balance and lead to a hard dough.

Kneading on a floured surface might help with the stickiness but can also have negative effects on the final outcome.

Your best bet is to find a great recipe, with no need to knead on a floured surface, and follow the instructions closely—being patient as you work your dough.

After fixing your dough, you should see a noticeable improvement in its texture. It should be smooth, soft, and ready for proofing to eventually become a delicious pizza.

Now that you know how to fix your hard dough, you can confidently create pizzas that you, your family, and your friends will enjoy.

Remember, practice makes perfect, and finding the right dough recipe for you is key. Continue experimenting with different recipes, techniques, and methods until you’ve achieved the perfect pizza dough. Happy baking!

Hope this article provides enough information on the question: “Why is my pizza dough hard?”. If you have any other questions, please don’t hesitate to contact us. Thanks for reading!

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does my pizza dough turn tough?

Your pizza dough may become tough if you’re kneading by hand and not being patient. It often ends up difficult to handle, full of holes, and not sticking together.

You might also be adding too much flour during kneading, making the dough too dry.

How can I fix a tough pizza dough?

To fix a tough pizza dough, slowly incorporate water a little bit at a time using a teaspoon. Do this in several rounds until you’re happy with the consistency and the dough is no longer hard.

Be patient during this process; getting a good dough consistency in the first place is ideal.

What causes my pizza dough to be dry?

Your pizza dough can dry due to too much flour added during kneading. Adding flour to prevent stickiness may destroy the balance of your recipe. It’s crucial to stick to the precise amounts listed in your recipe.

How to prevent pizza crust from hardening during reheating?

Avoid adding extra flour to the dough surface during kneading to avoid hardening your pizza crust while reheating.

Also, trying a different recipe might help. Opt for a recipe that doesn’t ask for kneading on a floured surface.

Why is my pizza dough difficult to stretch?

Your pizza dough may be difficult to stretch if it contains too much flour and lacks the proper balance of ingredients.

If you’re kneading by hand, be patient and give the dough enough time to develop the correct texture. Stick to the measurements specified in the recipe for the best results.

How can I make my pizza dough soft and pliable?

To create a soft and pliable pizza dough, stick to the measurements in your recipe, knead patiently, and avoid adding extra flour to the surface during kneading.

Additionally, ensure that you allow the dough to rest and properly proof before rolling it out.

Photo of author


Sarah is a passionate pizza lover who enjoys exploring the world of pizza. She believes that pizza is not just a food, but an art form that brings people together. Through her writing, Sarah aims to share her love for pizza and provide useful tips, recipes, and insights to help pizza enthusiasts of all levels. Whether you're a seasoned pizza lover or a newcomer to the world of pizza, Sarah's articles will guide you through the vast and delicious world of pizza. Join her on a journey to discover the best pizza recipes, cooking techniques, and insider tips, all served with a side of love for the ultimate pizza experience.

Leave a Comment

beautifulsouthrestaurant.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates.